Some chefs see a round slab of dough and visualize a transformative work of art consisting of fresh, colorful ingredients and creamy, savory sauces. These pizza connoisseurs are heroes in the eyes of pizza lovers everywhere. Bring your family closer together by experiencing the taste of innovative or traditional pizzas together at one of these pizza places in Broken Arrow, OK.
Drive on Over: 5 Great Pizza Places Near Broken Arrow, OK
1. Andolini's Pizzeria
The menu at this Italian restaurant located at 222 S Main Street features many fresh ingredients made in-house, including dough, crusts, sauces, mozzarella cheese, sausage, and dressings! We love knowing that anything on the menu includes freshly handmade components without being kept in the freezer first. Start things off with an appetizer of Arancini, crispy fried risotto balls stuffed with cheese and basil, while you browse the pizza menu. Specialty pizzas include the Cinco de Cuatro with pepperoni, Calabrian sausage, fried jalapenos, and spicy honey; the Peppa Pig with peppadew peppers, sweet piquante, pancetta, genoa salami, ricotta, and spicy honey.
2. Franco's Pizza & Trattoria
Located at 527 West Washington St S, this slice of Italy is notorious throughout Oklahoma for its homemade pasta, hand-crafted desserts, and award-winning pizzas, all curated with authentic Italian ingredients. The pizza menu features a range of pizza styles, including Chicago deep dish, thin crust, gluten-free, and traditional Italian Margherita.
3. Uncle Vinny's NY Pizzeria
This beloved Italian eatery located at 322 W Kenosha Street offers a lively atmosphere and a friendly vibe, served with a heaping helping of Italian seasoning. You'll find creative combinations like the Lady Liberty Pizza with garlic oil, cream cheese, chicken, jalapenos and strawberry sauce; and the Funky Chicken Pizza with red sauce, mozzarella, chicken, bacon, pineapple, jalapeno and BBQ sauce.
4. Zoies Pizzeria
This local favorite found at 2424 W New Orleans Street has the community buzzing about its superhero-inspired pizzas and calzones that are like something from an alternate universe. The menu at Zoies will challenge the most audacious pizza fanatic with wild items like The Captain America Pizza with hamburger, bacon, pickles, and mustard; or the Vulcan Pizza with beef, salsa, re-fried beans, jalapenos, and lettuce.
For those less daring, the Iron Man Deep Dish Pizza is a bold explosion of pepperoni and cheese, and the Spiderman is a classic blend of five cheeses. For dessert, order the Oreo Pizza to satisfy your sweet tooth.
5. Jimmy's New York Pizzeria
Drive over in your 2022 Ford Bronco Sport Big Bend to Jimmy's at 3312 S Elm Place and order a perfectly greasy New York Slice coming in at a whopping 12 inches long. Or order a full pie from traditional and specialty pizzas like the Bronx Chicken Alfredo with garlic alfredo sauce, fresh mozzarella, chicken, and bacon.
When you've satisfied your deep dish craving, swing by and see us at Matthews Ford to browse our new selection!